Holidaymakers could pay considerably more for their car hire if they fail to shop around, with some providers costing hundreds more than others, according to a new summer price study by iCarhireinsurance.com, a leading provider of standalone car hire excess reimbursement insurance.

The widest price variation was in Dubrovnik, where the cost of a week’s car hire ranged from £261 with one provider to £871 with another. A difference of £610 or 234%.

The study compared the cost of hiring a medium compact car, such as a VW Golf or Ford Focus, from 25 July to 1 August 2026. Prices from Avis, Budget, Enterprise, Europcar, Hertz and Sixt were surveyed across seven popular holiday destinations: Barcelona, Crete, Dubrovnik, Faro, Nice, Dalaman and Milan.

Faro had the next biggest price gap, with rates ranging from £390 with one provider to £796 with another provider, a difference of £406, or 104%.

Significant differences were also found in Milan, where prices ranged from £373 to £547, a difference of £174 or 47%, and Dalaman, where prices ranged from £337 to £487, a difference of £150 or 45%.

Destination Cheapest rate Most expensive rate Difference % more
Dubrovnik £261 £871 £610 234%
Faro £390 £796 £406 104%
Milan £373 £547 £174 47%
Dalaman £337 £487 £150 45%
Nice £301 £401 £100 33%
Crete £344 £423 £79 23%
Barcelona £257 £315 £58 23%
Average £323 £549 £226 70%

Holidaymakers should also look beyond the headline rental price and consider the cost of optional extras and excess protection. Across the seven destinations, an additional driver costs £68 on average for a week, a sat nav £76, a week's super damage waiver excess is £196, plus £51 for separate tyre and windscreen excess cover, adding £391 to the bill if all are purchased.

The excess is the amount drivers could be liable to pay if the hire car is damaged or stolen, even if it is not their fault, and averaged more than £1,600 in this study.

Buying excess protection in advance from a standalone provider can significantly reduce this. A standalone excess reimbursement policy from iCarhireinsurance.com costs from £33.152 for a week or £41.992 for an annual European policy.

“It can be easy to assume that car hire prices will be broadly similar, but our research shows just how much they can vary between rental companies,” said Ben Wooltorton at iCarhireinsurance.com. “Taking a few minutes to compare prices before booking could save a significant amount.

“It’s also important to look beyond the headline rental price. Extras can quickly add to the cost, and one easy saving is buying a standalone excess reimbursement policy in advance from a specialist provider like iCarhireinsurance.com, rather than excess protection at the rental desk, potentially saving over £200.”

1 The study by iCarhireinsurance.com compared the cost of hiring a medium compact car (and extras such as excess protection, car seats, extra driver & satnavs), such as a VW Golf or Ford Focus, from 25 July to 1 August 2026. Quotes from Avis, Budget, Enterprise, Europcar, Hertz and Sixt were surveyed across Barcelona, Crete, Dubrovnik, Faro, Nice, Dalaman and Milan

2 £33.15 based on a 30-year-old UK resident buying an 8-day single trip car hire excess policy from iCarhireinsurance.com for use in Europe. £41.99 annual price is based on a UK resident aged between 30-80 purchasing an excess Europe annual policy excluding in-country (UK) cover.

Disclaimer: All prices contained in this article were correct on the original date of publication. Prices may change over time, so for current prices, please get a quote.